Sleep Training Methods Comparison

Find the perfect sleep training method for your baby's temperament and your family's needs with our comprehensive comparison tool and personalized recommendations.

Find My Method Compare Methods

Sleep Training Method Finder

Answer a few questions about your baby and family preferences to get personalized sleep training method recommendations tailored to your specific situation.

Find Your Perfect Sleep Training Method

Interactive Method Comparison

Select sleep training methods to compare side-by-side. See detailed information about approach, timeline, pros and cons, and suitability for different situations.

Select Methods to Compare

Ferber Method

Progressive waiting

Difficulty: Medium

Extinction (CIO)

Cry it out method

Difficulty: High

Chair Method

Gradual retreat

Difficulty: Medium

No-Cry Method

Gentle approach

Difficulty: Low

Camping Out

Gradual withdrawal

Difficulty: Medium

Fading Method

Gradual reduction

Difficulty: Low

Complete Sleep Training Methods Guide

In-depth information about each sleep training method to help you make the best decision for your family

Understanding Sleep Training

Sleep training is the process of teaching your baby to fall asleep independently and sleep through the night. It's not about abandoning your baby, but rather giving them the valuable life skill of healthy sleep habits. The key is choosing a method that aligns with your family's values, your baby's temperament, and your comfort level.

When to Start

  • • 4-6 months old (earliest recommended age)
  • • Baby weighs at least 12-14 pounds
  • • Can go 4-6 hours without feeding
  • • No major developmental leaps in progress
  • • Family is ready for consistency

When NOT to Start

  • • During illness or teething
  • • Major life changes (moving, travel)
  • • Sleep regressions in progress
  • • Starting daycare within 2 weeks
  • • Parents not committed to consistency

Ferber Method (Progressive Waiting)

How It Works:

  1. 1. Put baby down awake but drowsy
  2. 2. Leave the room
  3. 3. Return for brief comfort checks at increasing intervals
  4. 4. Gradually extend time between checks
  5. 5. Repeat pattern until baby sleeps independently

Timeline:

Night 1: Check after 3, 5, 7 minutes
Night 2: Check after 5, 10, 15 minutes
Night 3: Check after 7, 15, 20 minutes
Results: Usually 3-7 days
Pros:
  • • Quick results (3-7 days)
  • • Clear structure and guidelines
  • • Allows for some comfort
  • • Well-researched method
  • • Works for most babies
Cons:
  • • Involves controlled crying
  • • Can be emotionally difficult
  • • May not suit sensitive babies
  • • Requires consistency from all caregivers
  • • Can disrupt other family members
Best For:

Parents comfortable with some crying, babies 6+ months old with easy-going temperaments, families needing quick results, babies without major sleep associations.

Extinction Method (Cry It Out)

How It Works:

  1. 1. Complete bedtime routine
  2. 2. Put baby down awake
  3. 3. Leave the room and don't return
  4. 4. Allow baby to self-soothe completely
  5. 5. Return only in morning or for scheduled feeds

Timeline:

Night 1: Often 30-60+ minutes crying
Night 2: Usually less crying
Night 3: Minimal crying typically
Results: Usually 2-5 days
Pros:
  • • Fastest results (2-5 days)
  • • No mixed messages to baby
  • • Clear and simple approach
  • • Highly effective for most babies
  • • Least confusing method
Cons:
  • • Most emotionally difficult for parents
  • • Involves extended crying periods
  • • Not suitable for all temperaments
  • • May feel too harsh for some families
  • • Can affect neighboring families
Best For:

Parents comfortable with crying, babies 6+ months with persistent temperaments, families needing immediate results, babies with strong sleep associations, situations where partial intervention makes things worse.

Chair Method (Sleep Lady Shuffle)

How It Works:

  1. 1. Sit in chair next to baby's crib
  2. 2. Provide minimal verbal/physical comfort
  3. 3. Move chair farther away every 3 days
  4. 4. Eventually move chair outside the room
  5. 5. Gradually reduce your presence entirely

Timeline:

Days 1-3: Chair beside crib
Days 4-6: Chair halfway to door
Days 7-9: Chair by door
Days 10+: Outside room, then done
Pros:
  • • Gentle, gradual approach
  • • Parent remains present for comfort
  • • Less crying than extinction methods
  • • Good for anxious babies
  • • Allows for some soothing
Cons:
  • • Takes longer (2-3 weeks)
  • • Requires significant time commitment
  • • May be stimulating for some babies
  • • Can create new sleep associations
  • • Progress may be inconsistent
Best For:

Parents wanting to stay present, sensitive or anxious babies, families preferring gradual changes, parents uncomfortable with crying methods, babies who find parent presence calming rather than stimulating.

No-Cry Sleep Solution

How It Works:

  1. 1. Make multiple small adjustments
  2. 2. Change sleep associations gradually
  3. 3. Optimize sleep environment
  4. 4. Adjust schedule and routine
  5. 5. Use gentle soothing techniques

Components:

• Sleep log analysis
• Environmental optimization
• Schedule adjustments
• Gradual routine changes
• Gentle weaning techniques
Pros:
  • • No crying involved
  • • Maintains attachment bonds
  • • Gentle on baby and parents
  • • Addresses underlying causes
  • • Suitable for any age
Cons:
  • • Takes longest time (weeks to months)
  • • Results may be gradual and subtle
  • • Requires patience and persistence
  • • May not work for all situations
  • • Less structured approach
Best For:

Parents opposed to any crying, highly sensitive babies, breastfeeding mothers, co-sleeping families, babies under 4 months, families with unlimited patience for gradual progress.

Keys to Sleep Training Success

Before You Start

  • • Choose a method that fits your family
  • • Ensure baby is healthy and ready
  • • Plan for 2-3 weeks of consistency
  • • Get all caregivers on board
  • • Optimize the sleep environment
  • • Have realistic expectations

During Training

  • • Stay consistent with your chosen method
  • • Track progress with a sleep log
  • • Take care of your own needs
  • • Be patient with temporary setbacks
  • • Celebrate small improvements
  • • Adjust expectations for your child's personality

Remember

There's no one-size-fits-all approach to sleep training. What works for one baby may not work for another. Trust your instincts, be patient with the process, and don't hesitate to modify your approach if needed. The goal is better sleep for the whole family, achieved in a way that feels right for you.

Master Any Sleep Training Method

While understanding different methods is crucial, having a comprehensive, step-by-step system can make all the difference. The Baby Sleep Miracle program provides detailed guidance for implementing any sleep training method successfully, with personalized support for your family's unique situation.

Get the Complete Sleep Training Guide

Join thousands of families who have successfully implemented their chosen sleep training method